5 min read

The Balancing Act: Tradition Meets Transformation

The Balancing Act: Tradition Meets Transformation

For generations, the commercial insurance industry has thrived on a foundation of trust, expertise, and personalized service. Brokers have built strong relationships with clients, acting as advisors and advocates while navigating the complexities of risk management. 

Carriers, on the other hand, have honed their underwriting skills, meticulously assessing risk profiles to ensure financial stability. Together, brokers and carriers have become a well-oiled machine delivering stability and security to countless businesses.

However, the winds of change are blowing strong. 

The insurance landscape is undergoing a digital revolution, driven by advancements in technology like artificial intelligence (AI), big data, and automation. Customer expectations are evolving too, with a growing demand for faster, more streamlined experiences. To navigate this new reality, broker and carrier leaders need to embrace a new kind of leadership – Agile Leadership.


Agile Leadership for the Modern Workplace

There are many great leaders among us. But those, I believe, who elevate their organizations above the rest instinctively know and embrace agile leadership. 

In a nutshell, agile leadership emphasizes adaptability, collaboration, and responsiveness in complex environments. It emerged from the world of agile software development but has become a broader approach to leading teams in any field, including commercial insurance.

Here are some key characteristics of agile leadership:

  • Focus on collaboration and communication: Agile leaders value teamwork and open communication. They use tools and processes that encourage cross-functional collaboration and break down silos between departments.
  • Adaptability and responsiveness: Agile leaders understand that plans change and are comfortable adjusting courses as needed. They are quick to learn from mistakes and iterate on their approach.
  • Empowering teams: Agile leaders trust their teams to make decisions and get things done. They provide support and coaching but avoid micromanaging.
  • Focus on value: Agile leaders are laser-focused on delivering value to customers. They prioritize tasks and projects that will have the biggest impact.
  • Embracing change: Agile leaders recognize change will be difficult at times, but do not waver from their commitment to leading their organizations and seeing digital transformation through. 


Agile leadership is powerful when deployed properly and consistently. And if you believe your organization is too rooted in its ways to accept an agile leader, think again. 

IBM, perhaps one of the most stoic logos in business, was known as a rigid stalworth within the technology industry. Scott Ambler changed that when he became “the face of Agile at IBM,” and championed the adoption of agile within large organizations. His work includes the development of new methodologies such as agile data, agile modeling, the unified process, and disciplined agile delivery. If IBM can become agile, so too can your brokerage or company. 


A Systemic Approach to Innovation

Simon Sinek, renowned leadership expert, famously said, "Innovation distinguishes between a leader and a follower."  So, how can leaders become true innovators while staying true to their core strengths? 

Here's a practical approach:

  • Embrace a Digital Lens: Conduct a thorough review of your existing processes – from underwriting and claims management to client onboarding and marketing. Analyze each step through a "digital lens," identifying opportunities for automation, data integration, and streamlining.
  • Leverage the Power of SWOT: Utilize the classic SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) framework to evaluate your organization's current position in the digital landscape. Identify areas where technology can enhance your existing strengths or mitigate potential weaknesses.
  • Prioritize Experimentation: Don't get bogged down in lengthy planning processes. Instead, encourage a culture of experimentation within your organization. Allocate resources for small-scale pilot projects to test the efficacy of new technologies and processes.


The challenge for insurance leaders lies in striking a delicate balance between the successful processes of the past and the power of digitization. To this end, leaders should honor their organizations' legacy while simultaneously embracing digital innovation's transformative potential. 


The Human Touch in a Digital World

The rise of automation in insurance does not spell the end of human interaction. In fact, the human element remains central to success in the commercial insurance space.

As AI takes over more routine tasks like data analysis and initial risk assessments, the value of human expertise will only increase. Experienced brokers will be critical in providing clients with strategic guidance and navigating complex risk scenarios. For as powerful as technology becomes, the one thing it cannot replace is the trust built between broker and client – never more so than when claims occur and when the rubber meets the road, and brokers really earn their salt.

So, instead of replacing human interaction, digital tools will actually enhance it. Imagine a broker armed with real-time data on a client's industry trends and risk profile. This allows them to deliver more targeted risk mitigation strategies and personalized service, strengthening client relationships. Let’s go further and consider the power of AI-powered chatbots handling basic inquiries and customer service requests, freeing up human agents to focus on complex cases and building stronger client relationships.

While some jobs focused on repetitive tasks will surely be replaced by digitalization, what will emerge are more positions where humans return to becoming the face of an organization and the relationships they build. 


Small Wins, Big Impact

The traditional insurance industry often relies on large-scale, waterfall project management methodologies. Projects that follow sequential phases with clear deliverables that must be met before moving on. 

Waterfall projects, with their rigid timelines and sequential phases, work for narrowly scoped projects but are not well-suited for the fast-paced world of digital innovation. 

In today's dynamic environment, agility is key, and this is precisely where agile leadership comes in. Agile leaders emphasize rapid experimentation and break down projects into smaller, more manageable chunks. This allows quick prototyping and testing, enabling course correction based on real-time data and user feedback.

But this approach requires brokers to do something they want to resist - fail fast

Brokers and carriers with leadership who champion the concept of "failing fast" and learning from mistakes quickly will move forward at an accelerated pace. It's easier said than done, for sure. But by not waiting for the perfect, all-encompassing solution and instead celebrating small wins, organizations will build momentum through incremental improvements. This can be difficult at times, as not all organizations are used to failure, but agile leaders must keep the big picture in mind and see things through; even when the going gets tough. 

As Satya Nadella, CEO of Microsoft, observed, "Your customers are changing faster than you are, and unless you are constantly innovating, you are going to become irrelevant."


Culture and Data: Building the Foundation to Win

Imagine trying to build a championship race car with subpar fuel. That's what it's like leading an agile team without a strong foundation of data and culture. The engine will continue to sputter and cough, never reaching its full potential.

For agile leadership to flourish, we need the right ingredients in the tank. Here's what that looks like:


Develop Data Quality and Governance  

High-quality data is the high-octane fuel for agile innovation.  Here are some actionable steps to get your data firing on all cylinders:

  • Step 1: Conduct a data quality assessment. Think of it as taking your data to the mechanic. Identify areas where accuracy or accessibility needs a tune-up.
  • Step 2: Implement data governance policies. These are like the rules of the road for your data – clear ownership, collection methods, and usage guidelines keep everyone on the same page.
  • Step 3: Invest in data management tools and training programs. Equip your team with the skills they need to handle this powerful fuel effectively.


Create a Culture of Experimentation

Agile leadership thrives in a culture that feels more like a top-notch racing pit crew than a dusty old garage. Here's how to foster that environment:

  • Step 1: Encourage open communication and collaboration across teams. Break down silos and get everyone talking!
  • Step 2: Implement processes for gathering and incorporating employee feedback. Feedback is like the pit crew's post-race debrief – invaluable for continuous improvement.
  • Step 3: Recognize and reward employees who take calculated risks and learn from failures. These are your fearless drivers who push the boundaries and learn from every lap. 
  • Step 4: Celebrate small wins and milestones achieved through experimentation. progress and keep the momentum going.
  • Step 5: Consider allocating a dedicated budget for experimentation projects. This putting your money where your mouth is – a tangible sign of your commitment to innovation.
  • Step 6: Commit to innovation and embracing change. Digitization is a bumpy road, and you need to be prepared for this. When things are not going as smoothly as you like, avoid panic and take on a problem solvers mindset. 


By taking these steps, you can build a solid foundation for agile leadership and empower your team to become the ultimate high-performance team in the digital age. 

Are you ready to buckle up and take the lead?


If you’d like to learn more about how Highwing helps brokers and carriers leverage the power of technology, connect with us today. We would love to chat with you.

Fostering Collaboration Across Departments

Fostering Collaboration Across Departments

During the Vietnam War, a joint mission between the US Navy's SEALs and the Army's Special Forces, code-named "Operation Ivory Coast," targeted a...

Read More
The Real Reason Your Brokerage NEEDS to Modernize

The Real Reason Your Brokerage NEEDS to Modernize

Steve firmly believed their brokerage’s 5-figure investment in the latest software program, now with AI integration, would lead them well past the...

Read More
The Balancing Act: Tradition Meets Transformation

The Balancing Act: Tradition Meets Transformation

For generations, the commercial insurance industry has thrived on a foundation of trust, expertise, and personalized service. Brokers have built...

Read More